Day 85/100 (I think)
There are a number of things I want to write longer posts about but I am going to limit this one to just some reviews of what I have been reading! I am no longer sick - was a bit worried that I would fall too far behind on this study challenge thing but it should be totally fine, especially as I have picked a couple of shorter books for my final stretch. I’ll get into other thoughts and topics in another update but for today here are some reviews (obviously spoilers may be contained, if you care, although nothing major):
本好きの下剋上 (kids edition) review
I read volumes one and two of the kids edition which has full furigana. They correspond to volume one of the regular light novel edition but has some extra short stories and manga.
I am not a massive fantasy guy but I get on reasonably well with slice of life type stuff if I am in the mood. A SoL book will never be my favourite and I will likely forget about it within a few months but they are generally easy to read and good to read in 10-20 minute snatches to relax. It was exactly in that way that I enjoyed this book (or these books). I found things quite slow and draggy but that is something inherent to the genre. I honestly did not care at all about the setting and the characters were extremely two dimensional. However, this book knows what it wants to be and does it well. If you are a fan of this genre then you will likely love it. The setting and 2D characters are perfect examples of this genre’s tropes and the quality of the writing was good for what it is. I doubt I will continue reading the series but I can see why someone would like this. Not life changing, not thought provoking, still managed to read it without getting especially bored.
4/10 - high-quality pulp
禎子の千羽鶴 review
This is an anti-war book which tells the true story of a young girl who died from cancer that was caused by the bombing of Hiroshima, as told by her brother. The book is aimed at children so the language doesn’t get too diffuclt and any technical terms are explained with footnotes. The writer’s voice is a little old-fashioned and a little unusually 丁寧語 is used throughout. I guess the intended feeling is like a kindly old man narrating a story to the audience (an older elementary school child) and I think it manages to achieve that quite successfully. A final note on language difficulty for those who may read this book, the dialogue uses a lot of slightly old-fashioned Hiroshima dialect. For me this was not a big deal as I live in Kansai and most of the dialect I was already quite familiar with and the things I hadn’t see before I could easily infer. If you are not used to non-standard dialects or western Japanese dialects then I would suggest reading a short guide or something before trying this book.
On the side of the story. I actually had to stop reading this book at work as I found it too emotional. I finished the remaineder off in a day or two but I had to take breaks to emotional prepare myself. Sadako’s story is told as part of the exhibition at the peace museum in Hiroshima and when I visited it deeply affected me. Going into this book I already was aware of the story and whilst reading I was constantly reminded of the peace museum. I think a combination of knowing what will happen, being keenly aware that the story is real, the personal authorial voice of Sadako’s brother, and the fact that the tone is like someone trying to kindly explain the reality of war to children but without lying, together these things made it a very moving read for me.
7/10 - a very affecting anti-war book for children
改良 review
This is the debut novel by 遠野遥 which won the Bungei Prize. His second novel would go on to win the Akutagawa Prize.
This is a very short book but it is gripping and quite intense. I am still not quite sure how I feel about it and would like to read some criticism of it at some point soon. The language is very everyday and quite straightforward however the pace is quite quick and there are many quite shocking scenes of sexual assault and violence, almost immediately, which could be quite confusing for less confident readers (not to mention just emotionally difficult to read in general).
I don’t want to spoil the story here as it is so short it could be spoilt in a sentence or two but to say something without saying anything, the main character is a young man who wants to become “beautiful” and to do so he likes (or, perhaps, does not like) dressing as a woman. He is also extremely critical of how “beautiful” other people are. The story explores the relationship between beauty, sexuality, and gender. It is a fascinating vignette of a confused young man and the main character feels like something of a 2019 answer to Murakami’s 1960s based protagonist from Norwegian Wood, although less developed. In fact, that would be perhaps where my doubts about this story lie. It is fast, sharp, violent, and quite shocking but the cost of that is things are left undeveloped and unexplored. I would guess this is deliberate, aiming to get the reader to consider the themes on their own, but it also feels like Tono is still not confident in his abilities as a writer to really push into his themes more fully. Best to consider this a long short story and not a novel. If you’re a confident reader then I’d suggest reading this in one or two bursts or at least over a single day as there is a frantic and panicked coherence to the thing which could be lost if the reading were to be spread out.
I feel I should repeat my above content warnings here before recommending this book. There is very intense description of sexual violence, including scenes involving children.
7/10 - a provoking and well written character study which left me with questions
殺人出産 review
The eponymous book is a collection of four short stories. This is a review of the first story which is also by far the longest (about 40k characters). I will write about the other stories once I have read them.
I have read コンビニ人間 (by the same author and winner of the Akutagawa Prize) two or three times over since I started learning Japanese but not out of some love for the book but simply because it was one of the first things I read and it is short enough to revisit and read in moments over a week. It is a reasonable short novel which explores themes of gender and our general roles in capitalist society, especially post-bubble Japan - well written but ultimately if it didn’t have such a significant place in my Japanese learning journey I likely would have forgotten the details of it by now.
殺人出産 felt totally different and yet also very similar. The similarity comes from the writing style. I don’t want to judge an author from just two pieces of writing but the voice of the main characters in both works feel hollow, like they are shell people. This is arguably the point in both cases but it still made things feel a bit samey. The feeling of difference however is quite strong when it comes to the story. The premise of 殺人出産 is that in some alternative reality people can elect to give birth to ten people and therefore gain the right to murder one person, anyone of their choosing. The story doesn’t deal much in the implications of this beyond the basic human level. This is not hard sci-fi; it is more of a narrative thought expirement. Some simple details like men being able to have artificial wombs are mentioned but lore building is not the point here, if you can bring yourself to not ask too many questions. Rather, the story is focused more on the main character’s psychological dealings with this system, a system which is relatively new (within a 100 years). The story touches on some themes which are applicable for us here in this world as well, such as the massive shift in moral consensus that can occur within just 100 years and how younger generations will take the previous generation’s ideas and magnify them and distort them (so be careful what you preach). Overall it was a little on the nose, which I also felt for コンビニ人間, but well written and quite compelling. I won’t get into the psychological aspects of the main character too much as it leads to some very large spoilers but the final part of the story had my jaw literally drop and I was absolutely disgusted. Content warning as such: graphic descriptions of extreme violence.
6/10 - a well written predictable yet unpredictable little story
Okay, I’m gonna leave it there for today. Hope you enjoyed reading!