Help with tense

Hoping someone might be able to help with this, specifically how to determine tense in a sentence with multiple verbs.

As an example in this first sentence both する and 乾く are conjugated into past positive

But in this next sentence the closing verb 働く is conjugated to past past positive but 買う/たがる are not.

Is there any general rule of thumb for figuring this out?

1 Like

I am sure others can answer this more correctly from a facts perspective but as a fellow learner it helped me to more view it like this

In the first sentence what you are saying is “Because of A having happened, B” That is why it is past tense, if it was してから, it would be order of action, meaning “After I did A, B” which would also make grammatical sense here (I think) but it isn’t the intention of the sentence, you’re not looking to show the order of action of you ran and then got thirsty, you’re looking to express that your getting thirsty was caused BY the running you did in the past.

It may be helpful to remember から as “From” and expanding the meaning outward from there. So if its してから it’s “from doing A, b” this is order of action, but したから is “from having done A, B” This is like “because of A, B”

In the second sentence you’re using て form as “and” and you’re connecting the two clauses together.

I think the confusing part is that て can sometimes seemingly be saying something similar to から where it is expressing the cause/reason for B just like in this second sentence you provided. I am unsure if it is unable to rephrased as “買いたがったから, 週末も働いた. I don’t see why it’s not possible? But maybe it just sounds weirder like that and is less natural, or maybe its just simply not what the review sentence is looking for in this particular answer.

I think that starts to get into territory where someone else can better explain. I could be mistaken on some of this so others can feel free to correct me, but this is generally how I have been viewing it.

2 Likes

The tense of a sentence is determined by the last verb’s conjugation. As you may already know, Japanese sentences usually end with a verb, so that makes the tense of the entire sentence easy to spot. Therefore both of your examples are in the past tense.

Now, in terms of the conjugations of other verbs contained in sentences (other than the last verb), you’ll have to review each of those grammar points as it seems there’s a gap in your understanding of them. In this case, how the て form is used (and there are various grammar points that use it). The simple (SUPER BASIC) answer is that the て form can be used to connect verbs and can function as “And” in English. That’s the short explanation. However, for a more complete explanation (yet still not comprehensive by any means), check out this article:

As for から, here’s a simple explanation of it:

https://jlptsensei.com/learn-japanese-grammar/から-kara-meaning/

If you haven’t already, I encourage you to grab a grammar book or find method that teaches you the fundamentals of Japanese grammar. BunPro is a great resource, but only after you’ve learned the basics (at least N5 to N4 level). After that, you can use BunPro by itself just fine.

1 Like