Read anything that’s fun to you.
I can’t really talk about manga since I almost immediately went to novels and light novels.
When it comes to novels, starting out is extremely hard no matter how you approach it. And even “easy” novels use high level grammar here and there. Do whatever you can to make it easier for you. Read novels of which you already know the story through anime or manga, or maybe even through being familiar with a translation. That way, when you get lost you can find your bearings again. Also reading digital is probably the way to go for the first couple of years. You can read physically if the book has furigana, looking up words without furigana it is just not worth the effort when reading physical books. I buy the physical books and then download then yarrr the digital version for koreader.
if you for instance, like Frieren, there is a novelization with furigana. The novelization is based on the anime (which is in turn based on the manga) and covers season 1.
時をかける少女 is a short classic story. It’s quite easy, but it does get very sci-fi-y in the end with lotsa sci-fi words. The book is only 160 pages but that includes two short stories as well.
You can also find more books on LearnNatively, there you can filter for difficulty based on ratings of other Japanese learner users.
Also, I also live in a “Japanese desert”, but I still managed to get a decent collection of Japanese physical books through amazon.jp. They ship to me in the Netherlands, so I assume they ship to the USA as well. And you can view the website in English. Just order in bulk to minimize shipping costs. It’s still not cheap by any means, but the low Yen value makes it affordable, and unlike some websites you CAN pay with foreign credit cards. Of course, buying books while visiting Japan is still a lot better, but don’t feel too discouraged if you can’t find (or carry) everything you’re looking for there!