ないうちに - Grammar Discussion

English translation:
before it becomes
before ~ occurs
without

Structure:
Verb[ ない ]・ うちに + Action

View on Bunpro

1 Like

Two things on this grammar point:

I think it’s really good to compare it with ~前に, as the meaning is overall the same, but this grammar point adds the “negative” feeling to it.

Also, in the resources, the same resource is cited twice with slightly different formatting.

I also ran across this list of example sentences, it’s pretty good I think!
http://www.tanos.co.uk/jlpt/skills/grammar/sentences/?grammarid=455

Sorry for being a bother with all these grammar points, but I do it becaues I love Bunpro and I want to see it become an awesome product. Cheers!

3 Likes

Thank you for point these out to us! I have updated the related grammar section to include 前に and have added a note about it in the information section on the Meaning page. I have also removed the redundant resource listing and added the tanos link that you provided. Cheers!

We love you too! :bunprogold: :heart: :bunprogold:

1 Like

I think there’s a mistake in this example sentence,



I’m quite sure 冷えない should be the answer

1 Like

@en_velours
Hey :star_struck:

That’s actually my error, I changed sentence to ひめる because it sounds more natural that way, but forgot to change the word for conjugation :bowing_man:

It should be all good now.

Sorry for the inconvenience :bowing_man:

The “Fun Fact” section says 前に and ないうちに are used in very similar situations, with ないうちに focusing more on unfavorable results. The given examples don’t convincingly show that contrast, though.

The second example 知らないうちに家の前にあるラーメン屋が潰れていた uses the “without noticing / before I knew it” sense of ないうちに. I can’t think of how to swap it with 前に as 知る前に潰れていた doesn’t carry that meaning, so it doesn’t illustrate the difference the Fun Fact describes.

A same-sentence pair would make the point much clearer, for example:
雨が降る前に帰ろう。(neutral sequence)
雨が降らないうちに帰ろう。(act now, while it still isn’t raining)