Interesting, because I’ve seen a lot of people recommend graded readers on WK, and not seen even one post about them being too easy. I guess it depends when in the flow you do them. Since I’ve currently read 0 sections of sentences hanging together (say several pages of manga or a couple of paragraphs of text), I feel like graded readers can be a good place to start for me. Graded readers also makes it easy to find material at my grammar skill level and hopefully with few enough new words that I won’t be overwhelmed with a lot of vocab.
Why I think the books are redundant for me: I don’t need more example sentences, I need more text hanging together so I can start reading actual Japanese where context is a thing. Japanese is so dependent on context to actually understand it that I feel like reading sentences in isolation don’t have much function beyond when you first learn a kanji or word and even then only in the beginning. I don’t want to stick with learning material longer than I have to. I know from learning English that my skill ballooned when I could start consuming normal media, but to consume normal media I need to be practiced in that skill, and example sentences doesn’t do that for me. Instead with graded readers (and manga) I can start reading actual text hanging together with context that also use similar words.
Perhaps I’ll feel different when I get to level 20+ and there is only one sentence at WK. But then I currently can only read one sentence, and sometimes only if I’m lucky. I mostly look at the English translations of the sentence to get a sense for how the word is used, and I guess I will miss that.
Currently however, I basically feel, if I had to buy those books for the Japanese school I’ll be going to. I’d totally use them and probably find them useful (and also would use them for school so…). But since I won’t, I’d rather buy really cheap books at Bookoff so I can practice reading more normal Japanese.
The multimedia exercise book is interesting though and I’ve added it as a maybe buy. It basically depends on if I think I’ll have time to use it when I need it in my study journey.
For onomatopoeia, I was planing to get Jazz Up your Japanese with Onomatopoeia that Tofugu recommended (they had a couple of different recommendations, and I decided on this one). Do you have a review of onomatope? There was no look inside on Amazon so I don’t know what that one is like and whether I might want to get that one instead.
@lopicake I tried Memrise before, but not really their vocabulary courses, but the beginner Japanese ones. I found the interface all right. I’ve heard a lot about poor quality though from user-created courses so I didn’t try them. Any chance you have a link to the one you used (since I assumed you still think it was good)?
What is Torii?